Manatees Don’t Dream of Electric Boats

Manatees Don’t Dream of Electric Boats by Bethany Bruno

When Florida put the last gas motor in a museum, I clapped with everyone else. The governor cut a ribbon over a row of electric pontoons and smiled with his whole mouth. He wore a polo embroidered with a manatee, bright white scars stitched across its back. Old prop marks turned mascot.

The crowd cheered. A reporter shouted about clean water and a new era. I believed it. I wanted a cure that fit inside a headline.

For a week, the springs looked rinsed. Water ran clear under the boardwalk. The Gulf held still. Egrets stepped through shallows with careful legs. Manatees drifted in the grass beds, heavy and calm, chewing seagrass into long green ribbons. No metal roar chased them. Someone said the state had plugged in and forgiven itself. 

Then the calls began. 

Homosassa at two in the morning.

Crystal River at three.

Weeki Wachee before sunrise.

Manatees began to lose their bearings. They bumped seawalls. They circled with eyes open and whiskers slack. They nudged pilings as if pilings had changed their language overnight. 

Guides whispered about cows surfacing with red-rimmed eyes. Their skin held pale scars that looked new again under dock lights. A tour captain swore one surfaced beside his pontoon, looked straight at him, and shook, not from cold. From something deeper. From the body’s refusal to shut down. 

By week three, a lab biologist traced a finger over a map and didn’t smile once. The new motors didn’t scream. They hummed. A steady low vibration that traveled through limestone and mangrove roots and settled into the inner ear. No deep sleep. No drop into that dark place where bodies repair and forget. The hum built a fence inside the skull. You could graze all night and still wake up starving. 

Cows grazed without rest. Calves pressed against mothers who forgot the count and slipped under for a second too long. A calf in Kings Bay spent that second in a place with no air. Volunteers hauled it up with towels and prayers. It coughed water and blinked. The mothers kept circling. 

The governor returned in a second polo with tighter thread. He announced the Bureau of Aquatic Wellness Soundscapes Initiative. He called the hum a modern challenge and an opportunity for growth. He promised measurable results. He thanked donors with names on benches that would face the water until the bolts loosened. 

They hired me because I’d tuned soundtracks that shook teenagers without shaking bolts at Kennedy, and because I grew up on the St. Johns, a lazy river with a quiet that felt older than law. My mother ran an airboat outfit and loved the noise. She said it kept skeeters honest. I wiped blood off tourists’ shins when reeds kissed them. I rinsed prop scars from gray backs in a plastic tub, hose in one hand, throat tight with something I never named. 

Under a tarp that smelled of gas and wet rope, I made a private promise. I’d work with sound and teach it to keep its hands to itself. 

The Bureau handed me a badge and a desk that tasted of old coffee. A map waited on top, peppered with yellow pins for every spring that mattered. They set aside a small budget for underwater speakers and a larger one for consultants in linen who said “alignment” and “deliverables.” I asked for patience. They asked for numbers. 

I rented a white houseboat in a canal the color of cold tea. Sugar ants owned the galley. The carpet stain shaped itself into Florida. Morning sun drew rectangles on the table. Afternoon thunderheads rolled in and dumped warm pennies on the roof. Night pulled no-see-ums from every blade of grass. I wore a head net and rubbed lemon on my wrists because a fisherman swore lemon beat anything a lab could mix. 

My job sounded simple. Design a sound the manatees would accept as a friend. Put it in the water. Tune it until they slept again. 

I started with the easy things. Seagrass sliding in current. Shrimp crackle under mangroves. The soft whoompof manatee breath, then the long release, a sigh that made you feel watched by a kind eye. I filtered the motor hum and laid the old world over the new. 

The Bureau assigned two interns to keep me honest. One came from Gainesville with a shark tooth on a cord. The other from Tampa with a patch on his hat that read “MAKE WAKULLA CLEAR AGAIN.” They sat in kayaks while the sun burned the skin between thumb and finger. They fastened trackers to flukes with ropes that looked gentle and weren’t. They ate Publix subs under a bridge that smelled of bait and old beer. They wrote numbers on waterproof paper and left salt on their pens. 

I sat with headphones and closed my eyes. My head turns sound into taste and color. An ocarina tastes green. Shrimp crackle tastes of red dust beneath a truck. A manatee breath tastes of sugar and coffee. I built a mix with a tempo that matched a resting manatee. I found a low line that rolled under everything, tide moving under a bridge. 

We placed the first speaker under Three Sisters before dawn on a Tuesday. The water there glows an impossible blue that makes photos look dishonest. Guides tell tourists to hush and be guests, not gods. We got one quiet hour. The river granted it. 

I flipped the switch. 

Grass and breath and shrimp rose through the water, cool as a hand on a fevered forehead. Two cows drifted near. One rolled an eye, dark and patient. A calf tucked under a belly and brushed algae with its flipper. 

On the screen, the tracker lines softened. Heart rates eased. Movement slowed. A line that had jittered all night smoothed, the way a face smooths when someone finally stops listening for a door. 

The calf slept for three minutes. Then five. 

The interns whooped. I didn’t. I let out a breath I’d held since the ribbon cutting and tasted fear inside it. This could work. Florida could give back one thing. 

We expanded to Homosassa and King Spring. The Bureau sent a photographer who wanted lens flares on whiskers. He got two flares and a sneeze straight onto the glass. They sent a lawyer too. He said if anyone drowned near my music, it could be an issue. I said people have drowned in silence for a long time. He said silence billed fewer hours. 

The first side effect climbed out of the water and sat down on the dock with wet feet. 

Two neighbors woke on their porches with hair clumped as if they’d been dragged through eelgrass. A woman woke at the edge of the boardwalk with her sundress stuck to her thighs and a grin that made her face ache. She said she’d dreamed of a dark blue room full of mothers and didn’t feel alone. A teenage boy woke on a pool float under a screened cage and posted a video of himself blinking at dawn while his friends laughed in the comments. One man lay face down in a kiddie pool clutching a burger bun, his body rising and falling with the water, stubborn as wildlife. 

The Bureau labeled this an unforeseen variable and formed a task force for Thursday. 

Bureau of Aquatic Wellness Soundscapes Initiative

Subject: Community Impact Metrics

1. Average REM proxy uplift within 1,000 feet of broadcast site

2. Tourist Sentiment Index during boardwalk dwell

3. Manatee Calf Somnolence Duration (minutes per night)

4. Lawsuit Velocity (filings per broadcast hour)

Please trend positive on items 1 through 3 while trending negative on item 4.

Thank you.

The county called a meeting. They served coffee that tasted of ash and cookies shaped like starfish. Commissioners asked me to stop the sleepwalking. They asked me to keep the manatees asleep. They asked me to tune the sound so tourists would feel something important and still sign waivers with a smile. The minutes called this sustainability. 

On my way out, a woman in a straw hat caught my sleeve. “The manatees can take every dream I’ve got,” she said, “if they leave me one hour of peace.” 

Her husband said he’d bill the county for a ruined pair of loafers. 

Both truths lived in the same house. 

I moved the low line down. I lifted the shrimp. I tucked the breath into a pocket beneath the mix, wintergreen in my mouth when I listened. The sleepwalking dipped for two nights and rose again when a storm parked over the county and hit roofs with its fists. People sleepwalk when rain sings. That sits outside any manual but inside every Florida childhood. 

The Bureau posted new signs on the boardwalk in a friendly font. 

WELCOME TO THE SOUNDSCAPE

We hope you find peace and connection here.

For your safety, please stay alert near the water’s edge. Float with a buddy.

Thank you for helping us keep Florida serene!

A pastor from a river church held a press conference under live oaks by the ramp. He held a jar of spring water and said I’d trapped souls in speakers. He called my boxes chalices, and not in a kind way. 

The next day, a neighbor slipped on algae and broke his wrist during a midnight walk. He called it a nothingbreak. The lawyer called it a precedent. Lawsuits came in a damp stack. One signature looped like waves. One stabbed the page. The complaint called my work a nuisance, a trespass by sound. 

The Bureau sent the lawyer with coffee breath. He told me to reduce broadcast hours. 

“Manatees need the night,” I said. 

“People have more lawyers,” he said. 

I cut the night to three hours and saved the best mix for that window. I named it GRAZE 3 because acronyms make committees feel brave. The interns started sleeping in daylight and grew a third color under their eyes. The tracker lines flattened and lifted, calm chest on a screen. 

Commissioners voted three to two to pause broadcasts for two weeks. The county called it prudence. 

New signs went up. 

SOUND PAUSE FOR YOUR SAFETY

THANK YOU FOR YOUR PATIENCE AS WE OPTIMIZE TRANQUILITY.

On day six, the spring wore a tired film at the edges. Boats idled in the cut with foam bumpers that squeaked. A calf wedged itself against a warm intake and clicked for a mother who circled wide, her heart fast on our screen. Volunteers slid the calf free with wet towels and soft curses. 

I stood behind the rail with my hands on the slats and counted its breaths. I hit ten and lost eleven. 

That night I made Cuban coffee on a hot plate. Sugar ants moved over the spoon as if the spoon belonged to them. Thunderheads stacked to the west. 

I wished for my mother. She died under fluorescent light in an ER that used to be a citrus packing house. Her heart gave out while she sorted earplugs for the afternoon tour. A woman with sunburned arms cried and told me to blame no one. I blamed sound anyway. The airboat outfit went to a cousin, then to a bank, then to a man who sells rosé at sunset. I stopped riding on air. I crawled into frequencies and numbers that couldn’t lie unless somebody demanded they did. 

I slept two hours and woke to the houseboat rocking. 

A cow and calf bumped the hull with soft heads. Their breath came through thin walls. On a nearby dock, a human snored, wet and steady, in time with the canal. I lifted the blind. A boy slept with a pool noodle under his neck. A puffer fish hovered near his hand, eyes fixed, bead-bright. 

The interns had left a hydrophone in the seam where the vents fizz and the water rolls, a breath that doesn’tend. They brought me the file after the shutdown because the county wanted proof that our adjustment plan met the new tranquility targets. 

We played the recording in the office. 

The room filled with a murmur that didn’t come from grass or shrimp or breath. It sounded older than policy. It sounded as if the earth had started talking in its sleep. A simple line formed, repeated, trembled through my forearms. 

I pulled a spectrogram. Peaks where I wanted them. Gaps carved for humans. The pattern knit together with the certainty of muscle memory. 

And under it, low and rough, a sawtooth edge, the kind a body makes when it sleeps with its mouth open and its nose set wrong. 

A human line. 

My line. 

I recorded my own breath while I listened and saw its small fish flicker in the margin later. I broke my nose on a swing set when I was nine. We never fixed it. That was the kind of family we were. The snore sat under the chorus, steady as a confession. 

I tuned GRAZE 3 to the river’s line. I removed the Bureau logo from the file and tagged it LULL. Permission already lived in the water. I just stopped pretending I owned the gate. 

The night I broadcast LULL across three springs at once, a storm drew a red wall from Gulf to Atlantic. The weather radio sang its small alarm. Sirens honked on the highway. 

I stood at the console and watched radar smear a bruise across the county. I didn’t pull the plug. 

On all three screens, circles formed. Twelve animals at a time arranged at equal distance, each rising and sinking in turn. Calves slept while rain hit the river hard enough to turn it to smoke. The interns forgot their hats. Their hair curled into ferns. A ranger whispered that she felt as if she’d walked into church without meaning to. 

Humans stepped outside and tilted their faces up. Some walked to the boardwalk and stood in the rain with mouths open. Phones stayed in pockets. A woman who’d cursed the program sat on her porch steps and slept, jaw slack, hands empty. A man who’d shrink-wrapped his house in faith lay down under his own gutter and woke with a frog on his chest, quiet as a blessing he didn’t earn. 

Morning found limbs in streets, leaves in gutters, and a softness in grocery lines you don’t see in summer. 

I climbed onto the roof with a squeegee and pushed rain into the canal. The sky looked rinsed, the way the springs had looked that first week. A pull started in my chest that didn’t feel born in me. I had slept two hours, and those hours felt borrowed. 

A cow surfaced beside the boat and exhaled warm spray across my arm. I didn’t touch. The sign says don’ttouch. I spoke to the water anyway, the way I spoke to my mother when the monitor went flat. 

Sleep, I thought. Sleep, you beautiful stubborn body.

By September the Bureau held a binder thick with data and a folder thick with complaints. The governor returned to say the state had done what no other state had done and Florida might do a bigger thing in a bigger seat. A reporter asked if he credited the engineer with the headphones. 

He smiled with teeth and said Florida credits all Floridians. 

The Bureau gave me a plaque with a U where my O should be. 

A graduate student at the lab sent me a clip. The interns had dumped a month of hydrophone recordings into a drive named River Sounds Please Sort. He’d found the low sawtooth line. He looped it. The room filled with the chorus and my snore tucked beneath it, obedient as an organ pedal. 

He asked if he should report it as an artifact or a bug. 

“Hold it,” I told him. “A week.” 

I knew what a committee would do. They’d scrub anything that smelled of a person. People are liability. People ruin the brand. They’d clean the sound until it could hang in a lobby. They’d call it serenity and sell it. 

The Board slid a form toward me that shifted liability onto my desk. Every lawyer at the table called it fair. My stomach called it a trick. 

I signed. 

I went back to the water. 

The county put up a new sign, bold enough to sound like consent. 

BY ENTERING THIS AREA YOU CONSENT TO AMBIENT AQUATIC LULLABIES

DO NOT SLEEP ON RAILINGS. DO NOT NAP IN KAYAKS. DREAM WITH A BUDDY.

IN CASE OF TRANQUILITY, SIP WATER.

The Bureau wanted LULL without the human line. A consultant with white shoes called my snore an impurity. He said it confused the brand. He said judges like clean. He said prizes require polish. 

He didn’t look at the river. He looked at bullet points. 

I sat alone in the console room and watched the vents boil under a blue that hurt to stare at. The speakers hummed. The circle formed at dusk and again at midnight. Calves slept longer than any calf in spring memory. 

The Bureau filed a clean release with the state archive and removed the human line from the official LULL file. 

They left the speakers on. 

In winter the first cold snap rolled the palmettos and drove a gray fleet into the vents. Children leaned over the rail and counted whiskers. A ranger raised her hands and hushed. 

Breath rose.

Water sang.

A kid tugged his grandmother’s sleeve at the fence. “Listen,” he said. “The water’s snoring.” 

He was right. 

You could hear it from the boardwalk if you stood still long enough. A low rough line under the chorus, a body refusing to behave, a person still inside the system. 

The grandmother nodded but kept her eyes on the water. 

The river keeps some names. It turns the rest into sound. 

And out in the vents, the manatees kept circling in their dark blue room. They turned. They rose. They breathed. They turned again into the slow deep place where repair happens. 

For one hour, the world felt tuned. 

Bethany Bruno is a Floridian author. She holds a BA in English from Flagler College and an MA from the University of North Florida. Her work has appeared in more than a hundred literary journals and magazines, including The Threepenny Review, The Sun, McSweeney’s, River Teeth’s Beautiful Things, and The Huffington Post. A Best of the Net nominee, she has won multiple writing contests, including the 2026 Saturday Evening Post Great American Fiction Contest. Learn more at bethanybrunowriter.com